Which bird feeder to choose to attract which birds?
Our guide to choosing the right bird feeder
Contents
Autumn is well under way, and winter is already on its way. In your garden, insects are becoming scarcer, with most having already entered their hibernation or diapause phase. Birds are already crying out for food. Although most bird protection organisations recommend filling feeders from mid-November to the end of March, it goes without saying that everything depends on the weather conditions and the geographical area. In some regions, winter can arrive particularly early…
You have therefore decided to install one or more feeders, not only to ensure the survival of this winged wildlife, but also to enjoy a spectacle that is always rewarding. There are many different feeder models available, and you do not know which one or ones to choose.
Discover all my advice on the different types of feeders best suited to each species of bird. They do not all feed in the same way.
Which birds visit gardens, terraces and balconies?
Throughout the year, your garden is visited by flights of birds that come to feed, drink, and sometimes seek shelter or nest. In spring and summer, the garden becomes a vast feeding ground, with insectivorous birds finding plenty to feed their broods. Larvae and caterpillars of all kinds are a favourite meal for tits. Meanwhile, piles of branches, logs or even compost shelter numerous insects, spiders and invertebrates, much to the delight of the wren and dunnock. Ivy-covered walls, beds of berry-producing shrubs, fruit trees, and plants such as sunflowers, thistles and teasels, as well as areas of wild grasses, also provide a welcome haven for these garden birds.
A world of activity around the feeders
In winter, however, as insects become scarce, installing bird feeders helps make up for the lack of food. Most garden birds have a generalist diet, which varies with the seasons and also according to the geographical area of their habitat. During the breeding season, many become insectivorous to feed their young, while others are exclusively granivorous. In winter, however, as the choice of prey becomes more limited, many birds may visit feeders.

Great tits and blue tits, European greenfinches, robins and dunnocks regularly visit the feeders
In our latitudes, in the countryside or semi-urban areas, the most common birds to visit feeders are undoubtedly the great tit, blue tit and marsh tit, the chaffinch, European greenfinch, the robin, house sparrow, dunnock… not forgetting the collared dove, wood pigeon, magpie and blackbird, or even the common starling. In more rural areas, you are more likely to see the Eurasian nuthatch, European goldfinch, coal tit and crested tit, as well as the black redstart… More rarely, the wren.
Different behaviours
All these birds display different behaviours, often dictated by their diet. The blue tit, for example, has a short beak, ideal for catching insects and larvae on leaves, but also for picking food through the mesh of feeders. The chaffinch, on the other hand, has a strong, pointed beak, perfect for extracting seeds from their husks. As for the robin, it tends to feed on the ground.
Around feeders in winter, birds also display territorial behaviour. Robins tend to chase away any intruders entering their territory, while grey wagtails and European greenfinches can also be very aggressive around feeders. House sparrows behave in much the same way. Goldfinches, on the other hand, are calmer and often wait until the others have finished.

Squabbles often break out among the birds, with European greenfinches frequently proving aggressive
That is why, to attract the widest possible variety of birds, it is a good idea to provide several feeding areas, using different types of feeder and filling them with a range of foods, distributed across the garden.
On a balcony or terrace, there will certainly be fewer species, but tits and sparrows often still make an appearance.
Read also
What do the birds in our gardens eat?A few tips for setting up bird feeders
For a bird, a garden is full of dangers of various kinds. This is why a few precautions are needed when installing bird feeders:
- Do not install bird feeders too close to windows and glazed doors where the garden is often reflected, confusing the birds. If you only have a balcony, simply putting up curtains can solve the problem of birds colliding with the glass.
- Position your bird feeders in a very open spot, where birds will be able to detect danger. At the same time, do not place them right in the middle of an open space, as a Eurasian sparrowhawk could attack the birds while they are feeding. You should also avoid placing bird feeders in or near bushes, or in the branches of a tree, as cats, the main enemies of garden birds, could hide there while waiting for the right moment.
- Avoid installing bird feeders placed on the ground, unless your garden is perfectly protected from cats getting in.
- Although they are not a danger, squirrels (and even rats) may come and feed at the bird feeders, driving the birds away. To avoid this nuisance, the simplest solution is to fix your bird feeder to metal poles that squirrels and rodents will not be able to climb.

Competition is fierce and predators are numerous around bird feeders
- As well as cats, the Eurasian sparrowhawk is a real scourge for garden birds. To avoid a massacre (I have experienced it in my garden, which dozens of sparrowhawks fly over every day), the simplest solution is to install the bird feeders near thorny shrubs where the birds can take refuge, but the sparrowhawks cannot. You should also regularly move the bird feeders and install deterrents such as CDs, deterrent balloons or reflectors.
- Some bird feeders also attract large, more aggressive or voracious birds, such as gulls by the sea, European starlings, great spotted woodpeckers, crows and woodpigeons… It is often enough to provide several feeding stations. But the most effective solution is still to put food in bird feeders that are difficult for larger birds to access, such as mesh feeders. You can also learn to love these birds, which are just as charming as the others!
Otherwise, it is recommended not to put out too much food at once, to avoid squabbles. It is best to put the seeds out early in the morning and in the evening. When spring arrives and temperatures rise, reduce feeding, but do not stop it suddenly. Finally, it is essential to clean the bird feeders regularly to limit the spread of disease.
Also remember to install bird baths, even in winter.
Feeding tables: single but effective
Among the different types of bird feeders, bird tables are the simplest. However, while they are very practical for watching birds, they are also convenient for predators. This is why they must be positioned with great care, following the advice given in the previous paragraph.
Ideally, these bird tables should have a perforated metal base to ensure that rainwater drains away. They will also be easy to clean and perfect for seeds.
These bird tables can be placed on the ground to feed birds such as robins, dunnocks and blackbirds. But only if there are absolutely no cats visiting your garden! They can also be fixed to the top of a post, attached to a wall or suspended from a branch. The food can be protected from the weather by a roof, although this may frighten some timid species, or placed in a hopper feeder. The essential thing is for this feeder to have drainage openings. It must also be sturdy and firmly anchored in the ground with a stake at least 10 cm long, driven one-third of the way into the ground.

Tables or tray feeders, with or without a hopper
Easy to make, these feeders attract tits, sparrows, siskins and European greenfinches… as well as larger birds such as collared doves and woodpigeons.
Keen DIY enthusiasts can make their bird tables from wood, optionally adding a perforated metal or plastic tray, which is easier to clean. The wood can be protected with linseed oil.
Mesh and tubular feeders, silo-style, which are a little more specialised
Let us now turn to bird feeders in the strict sense, which come in two forms: tubular and mesh feeders. Tubular feeders are cylindrical silos, often made of perspex, available in various sizes and fitted with several holes and perches. These feeders are particularly useful because they are easy to clean and watertight. They also help to limit the spread of disease. This type of feeder is particularly popular with finches (goldfinches, hawfinches, chaffinches and so on), as well as tits.

Shop-bought or homemade tubular feeders
This type of feeder is not difficult to make, using just a few materials: a plastic tube, a gutter, a plastic bottle or container, a tin can…
The second option is the hopper-style mesh feeder, which comes in various shapes and sizes. These feeders mainly differ in the size of their mesh: small mesh is suitable for offering seeds, while large mesh is suitable for peanuts or sunflower seeds. Tits, greenfinches and nuthatches enjoy this type of feeder, sometimes hanging from it upside down. Once again, with a little creativity, it is quite simple to make one using wire mesh.

Mesh feeders
Finally, there are other types of bird-feeding stations, including hanging feeders, made from nets filled with seeds or peanuts, fat balls, “cakes” for birds, millet stalks… Some, such as seed or fat nets, should be avoided because birds tend to get their feet caught in them. Nevertheless, a simple wooden log drilled with holes, a pine cone or any kind of container, such as a cup, can be used to make effective and original hanging feeders.
Ingrid also shares a few ideas in her articles:
- Subscribe!
- Contents
This form is protected by reCAPTCHA - the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Comments